Journalism without inquiry is just storytelling without substance.

By Alagi Yorro Jallow

Investigative rigor is what separates true journalism from mere reporting—it challenges narratives, uncovers truths, and holds power accountable. Alagi Yorro Jallow Fatoumatta: The absolute silence of Gambian media practitioners regarding the arrest of an editor and a political commentator is deeply concerning. This lack of coverage raises serious questions about media integrity and suggests a troubling compromise or a deliberate act of self-censorship that stops the exposure of human rights violations against certain individuals. It increasingly appears that Gambian online media platforms are mere mouthpieces for the Senegalese government, undermining their role as independent watchdogs for justice and truth. At its core, journalism serves as an essential safeguard for democracy, bravely holding those in power accountable rather than merely echoing government narratives. A free press stands as an unwavering pillar of justice, ensuring that dissenting voices are not only heard but amplified. It must resist being selective in its reporting, rejecting any role as a propaganda machine for governments or their officials. Journalists have the right to pursue the truth without fear of persecution. Dedicated and professional journalists fiercely advocate for press freedom, defend the rights of their colleagues, and expose human rights abuses. They stand firmly against any government efforts to stifle the free press or target journalists for retribution.

As responsible journalist or journalists of conscience our laws, moral standards, customs, and modern civil rights exist to uphold the five fundamental freedoms of every individual: the right to life, the right to honor, the right to property, the right to faith (belief), and the right to express one’s thought (ideas and opinions). Protecting these freedoms is not merely a legal obligation; it is the cornerstone of a free society. When these rights are suppressed, it stifles the very essence of human expression. The moment one individual is unjustly deprived of these liberties, the fabric of society is threatened. Fatoumatta: The arrest of Simon Faye from Sen TV and apolitical commentator Abdou Nguer marks a blatant assault on freedom of thought and information. Alarmingly, this critical incident has been largely ignored by Gambian online news outlets, which seem more invested in propagating the interests of the Senegalese government rather than defending the human rights of journalists and supporters of previous regimes. None of Faye’s comments incited public unrest; any chaos would rightfully fall on those who instigate it. He is a journalist of integrity, not a disruptor of civil peace or our democratic institutions. The issue at hand isn’t whether Faye authored the controversial article; rather, his wrongful arrest embodies an alarming trend of intimidation that undermines the press, aiming to instill fear among Senegalese citizens regarding their ability to voice dissent—especially if their opinions challenge Prime Minister Ousmane Sonko or jeopardize his image. The mere sensitivity of a Prime Minister does not legitimize the prosecution of a journalist or a citizen, nor can it justify keeping him in custody. This ordeal represents a grievous abuse of power that contradicts the assurances made by the President during his recent media interaction, where he attempted to distance himself from these politically motivated arrests. Fatoumatta: It is abundantly clear to all observers that Prime Minister Sonko is the architect of these repressive measures, regardless of whether or not he explicitly directed the DIC (the Directorate of Criminal Investigations) or the prosecutor to act. In oppressive regimes, officials frequently operate as ardent defenders of their leaders’ images, acting without formal orders. The President's denial merely legitimizes a troubling pattern that many hoped was only a temporary aberration. Regrettably, the intimidation and manipulation of the DIC as a political tool continue unabated, contrary to the expectations of a hopeful Senegalese populace. Let us be crystal clear: every citizen has the right to scrutinize societal issues and express their thoughts on public actions and the authorities executing them without having to justify themselves. Every Gambian and Senegalese citizen—especially journalists, intellectuals, and analysts—should relish the freedom to articulate, publish, and disseminate their reflections, analyses, and interpretations openly. They possess the autonomy to interpret, describe, and critique events through their perspectives, guided by their beliefs and emotions. This kind of critical discourse is vital for a vibrant intellectual community. Journalists must be able to voice their criticism of Ousmane Sonko, Diomaye Faye, or any public figure without fear of reprisal. They should freely evaluate and interpret actions—such as Sonko's trips or visits—through their own lenses. They have the right to interpret decrees as power grabs and question the motivations behind inaction. This kind of discourse is not just a right; it is the lifeblood of civic engagement and accountability. Fatoumatta: New leaders must recognize that with their offices comes a responsibility to accept scrutiny. They are not above public evaluation; they are, in fact, servants of the people. Instead of retreating into sensitivity, these leaders should actively engage with the pressing issues that affect the Senegalese populace. The economic hardships currently plaguing the Senegalese people are dire and demand urgent attention. Citizens are not concerned with the Prime Minister's travels; they seek resolution to the pressing challenges they face daily. If he finds public scrutiny unsettling or feels the need to clarify his actions, it is incumbent upon him to engage constructively in public discourse. This engagement embodies the fundamental principles of democracy. Each leader, including the President and Prime Minister, must prioritize the security and welfare of the Senegalese people over trivial distractions; only then can they fulfill their mandate and earn the trust of the nation. Authentic prophets and revolutionaries are, above all, liberators who actively expand and deepen the rights of their contemporaries and the societies they seek to transform. They are celebrated for breaking the chains of injustice that bind individuals. The current regime’s governance has fallen short, failing to uphold essential public freedoms. Nonetheless, we still have the opportunity to enact meaningful change. We must allow intellectual and democratic vitality to thrive, resisting any attempts to suppress it. True transformation cannot occur without a genuinely free press. A newspaper’s editorial stance reflects its core values—standing either with or against those in power is a critical choice that must be honored. Fatoumatta: In this light, Gambian media practitioners should unite in solidarity with journalists across the globe. They must reject the role of propagandists or public relations agents for any government and instead commit to responsible and ethical journalism that upholds the integrity of the profession.